Thursday, April 7, 2016

Solar Storm Researchers Prepare for the 'Big One' with New Urgency

On June 20, 2013, NASA's Solar Dynamics Observatory spacecraft captured this coronal mass ejection (CME). A solar phenomenon that can send billions of tons of particles into space that can reach Earth within three days. Credits: NASA

The specter of a geomagnetic solar storm with the ferocity to disrupt communications satellites, knock out GPS systems, shut down air travel and quench lights, computers and telephones in millions of homes for days, months or even years has yet to grip the public as a panic-inducing possibility. But it is a scenario that space scientists, global insurance corporations and government agencies from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to NASA to the White House Office of Science and Technology Policy (OSTP) take seriously, calling it a “low probability but high-impact event” that merits a substantial push on several fronts: research, forecasting and mitigation strategy.

At a recent conference in Washington, D.C. that drew space weather specialists from academia, the federal government, the military and private industry, Louis Lanzerotti, distinguished research professor at NJIT’s Center for Solar-Terrestrial Research, summed up the implications of a massive, well-timed solar storm for today’s technology-based, hyper-connected global society:

“Since the development of the electrical telegraph in the 1840s, space weather processes have affected the design, implementation and operation of many engineered systems, at first on Earth and now in space,” noted Lanzerotti, a panelist at the conference. “As the complexity of such systems increases, as new technologies are invented and deployed, and as humans have ventured beyond Earth’s surface, both human-built systems and humans themselves become more susceptible to the effects of Earth’s space environment.”

In addition to disrupting communications and energy grids, what is broadly known as space weather – powerful bursts of electromagnetic radiation, energetic charged particles and magnetized plasma – has the potential to corrode water and sewer pipelines, to erase historical data stored in computer memory, to undermine military and security operations and to harm astronauts traveling in space.

The symposium, “Space Weather Science and Applications: Research for Today, Training for Tomorrow,” sponsored by the Universities Space Research Association (USRA) and the Space Policy Institute at George Washington University, focused on the growing urgency for both basic scientific research and the development of practical applications in the field.

“Once systems start to fail, (the outages) could cascade in ways we can’t even conceive,” said Daniel Baker, director of the Laboratory for Atmospheric and Space Physics at the University of Colorado-Boulder and also a panelist, who recommends increasing support for the development of engineering systems and devices capable of protecting Earth’s infrastructure.

In a 2013 report, Lloyd’s of London, the insurance market, put the population at risk of a massive storm at “between 20-40 million with durations up to 1-2 years,” depending “largely on the availability of spare replacement transformers.” The cost of such a recovery would range between $600 billion and $2.6 trillion.

The symposium followed on the heels of a conference late last year, “Space Weather: Understanding Potential Impacts and Building Resilience,” convened in Washington, D.C. under the auspices of the Executive Office of the President of the United States and also attended by scientists and engineers from academia and industry, as well as policymakers and elected officials. At that time, the OSTP laid out a multi-part action plan to address, as Lanzerotti put it, “civil societal issues related to all aspects of space weather.”

In an op-ed piece that followed, Lanzerotti, who was also panelist at that conference, called the federal plan “impressive for its analyses and coverage of the measurements, data, and models that will be required to ensure security under space weather events of all types—from huge geomagnetic storm-produced telluric currents initiated by coronal mass ejections to solar radio-produced outages of GPS receivers to radiation effects by magnetosphere, solar and galactic radiation to satellite drag effects from Earth's atmosphere and ionosphere.”

These areas are the focus of NJIT’s Center for Solar-Terrestrial Research, which has a variety of instruments in space and on the ground for observing and recording space weather, including the world’s largest solar optical telescope at Big Bear Solar Observatory, a solar radio telescope array in Owens Valley, instruments across Antarctica and aboard spacecraft in the Van Allen radiation belts. 

At the recent symposium, Tamara Dickinson, the principal assistant director for environment and energy at the OSTP, described recent minor storms that had caused disruption: a blackout in Sweden during which NASA also detected anomalies in deep space missions and several years later, the interruption of flight-control systems, again in Sweden, that halted air traffic.

Dickinson said the government is at a “fundamental turning point” in its approach to space weather planning and prepared to “take decisive action to address this risk.”

Ralph Stoffler, the director of weather, deputy chief of staff for operations at U.S. Air Force headquarters in Washington, said the Air Force was currently expanding its network of sensors to monitor space weather, including placing them on all of its satellites.

“We need data to support particular military operations,” Stoffler said, adding that the Air Force relies on GPS for missions such as piloting remote aircraft in Afghanistan from the U.S. “If we can predict space weather, we can have other operations in place or delay.”

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) has recently added space weather to its daily operations briefings. “We know there is a gap in our ability to assess vulnerability and consequences,” said Jack Anderson, a senior analyst at DHS’s National Protection and Programs Directorate, adding that while there is currently no scale for predicting the magnitude of a storm as exists for hurricanes, for example, “we need to develop that at FEMA.”

William Lapenta, director of the National Centers for Environmental Prediction at the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) said his agency’s goal was to track solar storms “from sun to mud,” to predict where conditions following a coronal mass ejection, for example, would be most intense in the ionosphere and on Earth in the form of underground electrical currents, and to calculate impacts on a variety of systems.

One of the near-term challenges for policymakers will be to set benchmarks for assessing the vulnerability of various technology systems and establishing thresholds that would trigger protective or recovery responses, said William Murtagh, the assistant director for the space weather, energy and environment division at the OSTP. There are currently working groups focused on these benchmark amid efforts to reach out to other countries to establish international protocols for aviation conditions, mitigation strategies and data sharing, among other areas.

“We do not fully understand those upper boundaries, but we need to … once we understand how big these storms are we can develop trigger points,” he said, adding that the Nuclear Regulatory Commission was interested in the “10,000-year storm – that’s what they need to know.”

“The technological and biological impacts of severe space weather events are now firmly in the federal government’s sights,” noted Andrew Gerrard, director of NJIT’s Center for Solar-Terrestrial Research. “All things being equal, increased research funding from the represented federal agencies will further bolster the incorporation of ‘space weather’ into our daily lives. Such development will enable the solar-terrestrial community to, for the first time, see a solar storm, track its approach, and prepare accordingly.”



  1. It will be just like the miners strikes in the 70s when the lights went out and all you had was candles and torches and a gas stove for cooking it wasn't as bad as you think it actually got people talking rather than being glued to the telly,
    So it's not all doom and gloom.

  2. Don't kid yourself, a grid failure from any cause, over a very wide area, becomes life threatening within a week. Having spent a week with no power on the Gulf Coast after Katrina, I can tell you that you are now dependent on electricity for your survival. Virtually nothing works without it. I was lucky to be in a house that was stockpiled with food, and the water only went out for a few hours. It isn't a good feeling when you open a faucet and no water comes out. Most water systems are pressurized by electric pumps. No power, and you get no water. After you drink the water in your toilet tank and water heater, you had better hope you can catch rainwater, because without liquid, you can barely walk after 3 days. In 7 days, you're dead.
    But let's say you solve your water problem. Ever go a few days without eating? No power means that the oil refineries shut down. So do the pumps which pump fuel out of underground tanks. Even if you somehow get some fuel out of a nearby service station, the weekly delivery won't be coming to you. What fuel is already in storage might go to critical government uses, like keeping nuclear plants from melting down. Their cooling pumps are electric. Hundreds of thousands of trucks won't be delivering food without diesel fuel. Groceries will be looted clean within a few days.
    Don't count on any help showing up because the Internet, along with nearly all other forms of communication, will be down. The only way you will know what is happening is if you have a battery, or solar powered radio. Some of the over - the - air broadcast AM & FM radio stations have generators to run the station for a few days. Once their diesel runs out, or the workers decide to go searching for food or water, you won't hear much information from them.
    After a few days you may decide to flee. To where? Got a full fuel tank all the time? A few other people might decide to drive somewhere else too. With no fuel being pumped, the roads will soon grind to a complete halt from stuck vehicles. Want to be stuck on a road in the middle of nowhere with no water or food, surrounded by hundreds of thirsty, desperate, and probably armed strangers? Good luck with that.
    So you decide to wait for the Mexicans or Europeans to bring you some food. Even if they could help, and wanted to share, it is physically impossible. The quantity of food needed is impossible to get to the interior of the country before nearly everyone would have starved to death. And armed, hungry people might prove tough to help. Imagine the difficulty of trying to put together such a rescue plan. It would take weeks to have any impact at all. That is far too long.
    So be under no illusion. Should the electric grid go down over a very large area for more than a week, and you find yourself inside that area, the chances of you surviving for even 3 weeks are quite small. Like with crude oil, we have let ourselves become dependent on electricity for our very survival.

    1. Thanks for your comment. I agree. Most people aren't prepared for small inconveniences, let alone a real disaster. I'd like to hear your Katrina story in more detail.

    2. This comment has been removed by the author.

  3. No Hollywood epic, Aaron. I fled my home in New Orleans 2 days before the storm hit for my sister's near mansion in Slidell. Stayed there about a week with no electricity. It was HOT! Used to work for City Planning in New Orleans. Warned US Army Corps of Engineers a year before Katrina hit, in a 2 page letter, that the levees protecting New Orleans were a disaster waiting to happen. They never replied. Sold flooder house to government 2 years after storm and moved to a house 21 feet above sea level, north of Slidell. Most amazing thing was how dark it was for week after storm with no Moon at night. You couldn't see the ground outside at night. The stars were so numerous, I could not recognize the constellations. I understood how the people used to think that the sky was composed of crystal spheres. That is exactly how it looked because it looked so 3 dimensional, exactly like glass with thousands of lights embedded throughout it. I was lucky enough to see the transit of Venus with my small Coronado solar telescope. Later bought a 90mm one. The Sun through it is an amazing sight. It almost looks like the image on this page. I happened to catch a solar flare early one morning while using the 40mm one on a tripod. They are white hot, even through the hydrogen alpha only filtration of the solar telescope. If a Carrington event hit tomorrow, the northern half of the US would be toast. Texans might be OK, since they have their own grid. And since the farther south you get, the less current is generated that would burn out the giant transformers.